The Curvy FashionistaThe Curvy FashionistaThe Curvy Fashionista
Notification Show More
Aa
  • News
    News
    Looking the the latest plus size fashion and industry news around designers, influencers, and community happenings? Your plus size media publisher has you covered with…
    Show More
    Top News
    Duo Boots Giveaway on The Curvy Fashionista
    #TCFTurns5 Giveaway: Step into Style With the Duo Boots Giveaway!
    10 years ago
    Big Fig MattressXTCFStyle Expo
    Big Fig Mattress Giveaway!!!
    4 years ago
    Celebrating 200k FB Fans- It is a Spring #TCFStyle Giveaway with Simply Be!
    Celebrating 200k FB Fans- It is a Spring #TCFStyle Giveaway with Simply Be!
    10 years ago
    Latest News
    TCTurns15! Celebrate with Us with a City Chic Giveaway!
    1 month ago
    Felicity is back with her 5th Felicity Hayward x Playful Promises Collection!
    2 months ago
    TCFTurns15: We are Giving Away 15 Gift Cards in this Eloquii Giveaway!
    2 months ago
    Meet Keia Bounds, the Costume Designer Behind All THOSE Looks on “Survival of the Thickest”
    2 months ago
  • Style
    Style
    Yes, plus size style options exist and we are here to share the latest style finds, news, updates, and plus size style tips & tricks…
    Show More
    Top News
    Plus size woman Walking
    LETS TALK: Design Elements in Plus Size Clothes that KILL ME.
    11 years ago
    Duo Boots Giveaway on The Curvy Fashionista
    #TCFTurns5 Giveaway: Step into Style With the Duo Boots Giveaway!
    10 years ago
    Celebrating 200k FB Fans- It is a Spring #TCFStyle Giveaway with Simply Be!
    Celebrating 200k FB Fans- It is a Spring #TCFStyle Giveaway with Simply Be!
    10 years ago
    Latest News
    Before You Start Shopping for Fall, Check Out These 5 Fall Plus Size Shopping Tips!
    1 week ago
    The Nina Sharae Experience is dripping with sexy, plus size swimwear
    1 month ago
    Felicity is back with her 5th Felicity Hayward x Playful Promises Collection!
    2 months ago
    If You’re Still Looking for a Fun Plus Size Bathing Suit, Hilary Macmillan Swimwear Has Got You Covered!
    3 months ago
  • Shopping
    Shopping
    Wondering where to find specific plus size clothing items for that special occasion or need? The best plus size shopping finds are here. We’ve done…
    Show More
    Top News
    Plus size woman Walking
    LETS TALK: Design Elements in Plus Size Clothes that KILL ME.
    11 years ago
    Spring #TCFStyle Giveaway with Hips and Curves
    Celebrating 200k FB Fans- It is a Spring #TCFStyle Giveaway with Hips and Curves!
    10 years ago
    Valentine’s Day Curvy Couture Plus Size Lingerie Giveaway
    A Valentine’s Day Curvy Couture Plus Size Lingerie Giveaway
    10 years ago
    Latest News
    Felicity is back with her 5th Felicity Hayward x Playful Promises Collection!
    2 months ago
    Here’s Where to Find the Perfect Hats for Big Heads Big Hair for the Summer!
    2 months ago
    Steal the Spotlight in one of these 15 Must Have Plus Size Little Black Dresses for the Summer!
    3 months ago
    20+ Plus Size Robes for Maximum Summer Style & Comfort
    2 months ago
  • Wellness
    Wellness
    Let’s talk about self-care, self-love, body image, and related topics to wellness and life as a plus size person!
    Show More
    Top News
    Torrid's Feature of Tiffany from On The Fatwalk
    The Enabling of Self Loathers and Shame – A Facebook Observation of Torrid
    12 years ago
    Rescue Stress relief
    Finding My Own Rescue Remedy & Taking Better Care of Myself…
    7 years ago
    Meeting my father and his/my family
    Staring into His Eyes for the First Time- Meeting my Father
    10 years ago
    Latest News
    5 Plus Size Pregnancy Myths To Watch Out For When You’re Expecting
    4 days ago
    The Labor Day Sales Our Plus Size Editors Are Shopping (And What They’re Looking For)
    3 weeks ago
    This Portable Humidifier is My New Travel Bestie
    2 months ago
    6 Tips for Raising Children (and Yourself) in a Body Positive Environment
    2 months ago
  • Lifestyle
    Lifestyle
    There is so much more to a plus size fashion lover and we are highlighting the various topics from plus size celebrity fashion and style,…
    Show More
    Top News
    Open Letter Tim Gunn
    An Open Letter: Dear Tim Gunn, Let’s Make It Work
    10 years ago
    2017 MTV Move & TV Awards, chrissy metz, plus size celebrity
    ‘I Wear What I Want, When I Want’: Chrissy Metz Slays In Red at the 2017 MTV Movie & TV Awards
    6 years ago
    25 women of color e1615188552216
    25 Women Of Color Who Paved The Way for Body Positivity & Plus Size Fashion
    3 years ago
    Latest News
    How Coco Chanel Helped Me Stay True to My Plus Size Self in Paris
    2 months ago
    6 Tips for Raising Children (and Yourself) in a Body Positive Environment
    2 months ago
    Meet Keia Bounds, the Costume Designer Behind All THOSE Looks on “Survival of the Thickest”
    2 months ago
    The Fatness Spectrum and Why it Matters
    2 months ago
  • Shop TCF
Search TCF
More
  • Events
    • TCFStyle Brunch Series
  • Curvy & Plus Size Fashion Resources
  • About The Curvy Fashionista
  • Advertising
  • Contact
© 2008- 2023 · by TCFStyle Media · All Rights Reserved ·
Reading: Behind the BMI: A History and Why The AMA is Discouraging its Use
Aa
The Curvy FashionistaThe Curvy Fashionista
  • News
  • Style
  • Shopping
  • Wellness
  • Lifestyle
  • Shop TCF
Search TCF
  • About
  • News
  • Style
  • Shopping
  • Wellness
  • Beauty
  • Lifestyle
  • Write for TCF
  • Contact
Sign In Sign In
Follow US
  • Login
  • Community Guidelines
  • Style Star Ambassadors
  • TCFStyle Influencer Network
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact
© 2008- 2021 · by TCFStyle Media · All Rights Reserved ·
Body Politics

Behind the BMI: A History and Why The AMA is Discouraging its Use

Can we talk about the latest when it comes to BMI?!

mightymurphin
Last updated: 07/25/2023
By mightymurphin 7 Min Read
Share
BMI - @kathyharvey.rd
Image via @kathyharvey.rd

Have you heard the news that the American Medical Association (AMA) has publicly declared that the body mass index (BMI) is an imperfect measure and is discouraging its use by physicians?

We know that fat people are treated differently, not provided with evidence-based care, fatally misdiagnosed, unable to donate their bodies to science, denied access to certain medical treatments, and prescribed weight-loss as a cure-all based on solely their weight and BMI. This policy change by the AMA happened in June and is finally a step in the right direction for the medical field. 

Plus size woman looking off Michael Poley of Poley Creative for AllGo
Michael Poley of Poley Creative for AllGo

A new policy was adopted by the AMA recognizing the issues with BMI because of the historical harm of this measure including its racial bias, which we will discuss shortly. The policy also states there are limits to what the BMI takes into account and it should NOT be used as a sole criterion of denial by insurance companies. 

The report by the AMA Council on Science and Public Health states, “Numerous comorbidities, lifestyle issues, gender, ethnicities, medically significant familial-determined mortality effectors, duration of time one spends in certain BMI categories and the expected accumulation of fat with aging are likely to significantly affect interpretation of BMI data, particularly in regard to morbidity and mortality rates. Further, the use of BMI is problematic when used to diagnose and treat individuals with eating disorders because it does not capture the full range of abnormal eating disorders.”

The History of BMI

BMI
Image via MART PRODUCTION from Pexels on Canva

Let’s get into some of the history behind the BMI and explain why the AMA is right on target with their new recommendations. The formula later used to calculate BMI was created by a mathematician in the early 19th century named Lambert Adolphe Jacques Quetelet. At the time, it was called the Quetelet Index.

The intent of his formula was to have a quick and easy way to measure the general population, it was not meant to be used on an individual basis and is based on data collected from generations of non-Hispanic white men. It does not consider the person’s gender, race, or ethnicity. 

Different ethnicities and races have different “healthy weights” based on research. According to the US Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Minority Health (OHM), black women have the highest rates of “obesity” and being “overweight” compared to other US groups.

But this likely means that since the BMI didn’t include Black men or women, or women in general, a healthy weight for the Black community may be different. In fact, a 2003 study published in The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), showed that higher BMIs tend to be more ideal for Black people.

In China and Japan, they have changed the cutoff for the “overweight” category from the US version, likely because people of Asian descent have 2X the likelihood of developing Type 2 Diabetes than caucasians.

In the late 20th century, health and life insurance companies replaced their own height-weight tables with the Quetelet Index and correlated an increased amount of body fat with an increased risk of heart disease. This matters because insurance companies then used this information to determine a person’s coverage and doctors used it as a way to determine if they would accept a patient at their practice. 

BMI - @kathyharvey.rd
Image via @kathyharvey.rd

In a 1972 article called “Indices of Relative Weight and Obesity,”Angel Keys gave Quetelet’s measurement its modern name, the BMI, and also supported its use. Researchers, medical professionals, the government, and more importantly- insurance companies, wanted a simple way to track “health risk” among the US population. 

Keys analyzed the adiposity-density and subcutaneous fat thickness of 7,400 men from 5 European countries, used the Quetelet index, and came up with the BMI as a simple way to measure body weight in relation to height.

In 1985, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) started to use BMI as a way to “identify obesity.”  So not only is this measure based on an old formula, not being used for its intended use, and based on only white men, it also makes no allowance for different body proportions in terms of the amount of bone, muscle, and fat in the body. Someone with strong bones, a lot of muscle, and low body fat will have a high BMI.

How BMI is applied today tends to make the assumption that you can’t be healthy if you’re over a certain weight. But there are people who fall in the “obese” category based on BMI and are completely metabolically healthy, just as there are people who may fall into the “normal weight” category are metabolically unhealthy. 

BMI - @kathyharvey.rd
Image via @kathyharvey.rd

The Impact of the AMA’s New Policy

When the news first came out about the AMA’s new policy, our first thought was “what about the new AAP Pediatric Guidelines?!” You can read more about those guidelines here. But basically, in January of 2023, the AAP put out new guidelines recommending behavioral treatment, obesity medications, and even bariatric surgery to children. These guidelines are based on the child’s BMI.

So if the AMA is recommending BMI not be used alone and is acknowledging that it is not a great clinical measure of health, how does that affect the AAP’s recommendations? Will those change? Or will children be further stigmatized for their weight?

It is our hope that with the AMA’s new policy, this means that the medical world is changing. We hope it means that more providers will adopt a Healthy at Every Size model and that this changes what providers are taught in medical school about fatness.

We hope this will lead to evidence-based care for each and every person, regardless of size.

TAGGED: bmi, body mass index, plus size healthcare
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email Copy Link Print
By mightymurphin Freelance Writer
Follow:
Christine is a fat liberation advocate from central Pennsylvania. She started the #BackOnTheRack initiative to help bring plus sizes back into brick and mortar stores. She also launched a plus size representation survey with the goal of diversifying the types of models used by fashion brands. Her social media platform focuses on accepting and respecting bodies regardless of size, challenging fashion brands to be more size inclusive, and discussing the struggles plus size women face in society. Christine is a freelance writer for The Curvy Fashionista and has been featured on various podcasts, in Yahoo News, the Daily Dot, and Adore Media.
Leave a comment Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

plus size pregnancy myths - Image via @fatpositivefertility
Body Politics

5 Plus Size Pregnancy Myths To Watch Out For When You’re Expecting

You May Also Enjoy

plus size pregnancy myths - Image via @fatpositivefertility
Body Politics

5 Plus Size Pregnancy Myths To Watch Out For When You’re Expecting

mightymurphin By mightymurphin
Beauty

The Labor Day Sales Our Plus Size Editors Are Shopping (And What They’re Looking For)

Micah Gause By Micah Gause
Five Hey Dewy facial humidifiers lay on a white background.
Beauty

This Portable Humidifier is My New Travel Bestie

Micah Gause By Micah Gause
raising children in a body positive environment - Image by @emberandace
Body Image

6 Tips for Raising Children (and Yourself) in a Body Positive Environment

mightymurphin By mightymurphin
fatness spectrum - Image by fatlip.com
Body Politics

The Fatness Spectrum and Why it Matters

mightymurphin By mightymurphin
R/J Review - Image by Strand Theater Company
Body Politics

Fat and Queer Representation Done Right! R/J Review

mightymurphin By mightymurphin
  • News
  • Style
  • Shopping
  • Wellness
  • Lifestyle
  • Shop TCF
  • Events
  • Get Featured
  • Plus Size Resources
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclosure Policy
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
Instagram Facebook-f Twitter Pinterest Youtube
© 2008- 2023 · by TCFStyle Media · All Rights Reserved ·
The Curvy Fashionista Logo
Welcome Back!

Please Sign in to Your Account

Lost your password?